Blogs Are Stupid

Doesn't anyone believe in Dear Diary anymore? What happened to the joy of putting actual pen to paper? And why does every ordinary Jane and John think they can write well enough to burden the world with their scribblings? It’s a mystery that badly needs solving. My first entry contains my thoughts about blogging and will set your expectations. The rest will probably be stream of consciousness garbage, much like you’ll find on any other blog. Perhaps we will both come away enlightened.

Monday, September 22, 2008

Art Is Free

I wrote this article a couple years ago and posted it when Blogs Are Stupid was in it's infancy. I dragged it out of storage, dusted it off and revamped it a bit the other day. I somehow got roped in to being the Cultural Arts Chairperson on the Middle School PTSA. At each meeting, one member is asked to do an "invocation" type thing for motivational purposes. It's my turn this week and I'm taking the easy way out by using this piece. I'm also using it to take the easy way out on my blog today, because I have a massive migraine. Enjoy.

Art Is Free

This week is conference week at my children's school. I do not expect to get a glowing report on either child, though they are both exceptionally bright.

My children are not conventional learners or thinkers. They process through experimentation, manipulation and sensory stimulation. They are both extremely creative and hunger for visual and tactile sustenance. They are known as “kinesthetic” learners and like other kinesthetic learners, they are often labeled as discipline problems and disruptors of classroom tranquility.

Public school does not know what to do with my children, and so, they are compartmentalized within the very narrow definition of "gifted" and farmed out a couple days a week to harried accelerated learning specialists who have too many students and too few resources.

The rest of the time, they must fend for themselves; technicolor thinkers in a black and white world.

When my youngest child was in second grade, the very timeworn issue of "lack of focus" came up, as it always does, during his parent teacher conference. The teacher, who was actually exceptionally well suited to her job and infinitely more patient with my child than I am, slid a worksheet across the table with lips pursed and waited expectantly for me to comment.

The front of the sheet you see, was utterly pristine. There was not one pencil mark upon it. The back however, was completely covered in graphite...a riot of shapes and shading that upon closer inspection revealed a very detailed and richly embellished medieval battle scene.

This is how my darling 7 year old spent the morning, while his classmates diligently filled in the blanks on their worksheets. The problem then was not lack of focus, but that upon which my son chose to place his focus.

The school my children attend provides art instruction once a week, and obviously, this is not enough to slake my child's thirst. He was simply seeking another outlet for his creative energy. Worksheets do not inspire or motivate a child who is moved by shape, form and color.

It was quite clear that she expected me to be as outraged as she was. But try as I might, I simply could not summon up the kind of indignation that I knew any conscientious mother would or should be feeling.

Here is why:

Since the dawn of time, man has used the arts to communicate, to create a tapestry of the human experience, and to give meaning to his existence. In the ancient world, a civilization possessed of a strong artistic culture was thought to have a citizenry superior in intellect and inventiveness.

Unfortunately, as our world becomes more technologically oriented, with great scientific advances and the advent of many medical marvels, emphasis on and interest in the arts has waned to the point of becoming almost inconsequential. Sadly, only 36% of American students receive the recommended minimum of one hour per week of art instruction, despite the fact that the benefits of arts education are well documented.

Numerous studies have shown that a comprehensive arts education helps children:

  • Learn more effectively in all areas of the school curriculum, including math and science.
  • Experience greater understanding of what they learn
  • Score higher on all aspects of the SAT.
  • Acheive higher levels of academic success in college.

According to research by Professor Shirley Brice Heath of Stanford University, young people who practice the arts are:

  • Four times more likely to win an academic award>
  • Eight times more likely to receive a community service award
  • Three times more likely to win a school attendance award
  • Four times more likely to participate in a math or science fair.

Simply put, public schools are failing our children.

As funding becomes increasingly scarce, and more and more emphasis is placed on standardized testing, our children are becoming one dimensional and creatively stunted. Classroom learning is tailored to those who are "normal" or "average", and those who fall above or below that designation are left to swim against the current in the vain hope of making it to shore.

They either dog paddle in place, placidly treading water and waiting for their peers to catch up, or they are dragged beneath the waves and held there while the rest of the school swims effortlessly by.

I joined the PTA despite an innate abhorrence of such things, to have a hand in changing this. On an individual level, I cannot address the ridiculous academic standards and uniform curriculum, but I can do something about the lack of enrichment programs available.

I submitted a proposal to the Administration for a parent led program that I had seen being used with great success at another area elementary school. The program is designed to achieve the following:

  • To educate students about artistic techniques, as well as art history and theory in a fun and age appropriate manner.
  • To foster a love of and appreciation for art.
  • To facilitate creativity and self-expression.
  • To encourage parent involvement.

The program required a very minimal commitment of one hour once or twice a month in which a parent representative would choose an artist from a pre-established list for the applicable age group (2nd graders just don't get Kandinsky and 5th graders are much too sophisticated for Pollack). The parent would give a short presentation about the artist's biographical information, as well as that regarding the artist’s medium, technique, and theoretical beliefs.

Parents were encouraged to be as creative as they liked in their presentations. They could dress as the featured artist; perhaps wear a beret or carry a palette and brush. They might speak with an accent or imitate a physical attribute. Following the presentation, the parent would lead the class in a related project, using what they had learned.

The Administration approved my proposal and expressed excitement about the program. I went forward; incredibly energized and full of altruistic vigor. My enthusiasm was short lived however. Despite relentless promotion of the program and shameless solicitation for volunteers at every possible school function, only ten classes out of 65 yielded a willing parent.

That's barely 15% participation in a school of over 1200. The program was shelved due to lack of interest. It was bitterly disappointing and in my opinion, shamefully shortsighted.

Parents, we need to wake up. Other developed nations are surpassing us at every level of education. Their children are more well-rounded, more intuitive, and more able to compete in a global marketplace because they are provided with artistic, literary, musical and theatrical instruction as part of their everyday curriculum. If we don't take a page from their book, our kids will soon be absent from the pages of history.

If we cut physical education programs, our kids get fat. If we cut enrichment programs, our kids get flat. It's really very simple.

Find a way to bring the Arts back to our kids. Here's a good place to start:

"There is no must in Art, because Art is Free."

....Wassilly Kandinsky


  • At 5:52 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Well said. You also may want to check out this organization.

  • At 7:46 PM, Blogger Middle Girl said…

    I agree 100% ! ! !

  • At 9:02 AM, Blogger said…

    Oh, we used to have the Art Lady come when I was a girl! She would do just as you said... I think I like the idea, but volunteer parents are a hard commodity...

  • At 9:48 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Wow, I'm proud to report that the school my children go to have such a program in place, it's called "Talking Cavas". I only think it's done once a month though-- but parents are the ones doing the presenting. I wasn't aware of all the statistics and studies done on this. Very interesting and very worthwhile. ~Kellie

  • At 3:09 PM, Blogger Cathy Burke said…

    You said it! I would consider my entire family "artists" from my goldsmith husband to my six year old kindergartner who favors thick black permanent marker on any surface. I remember having my placemat taken from me in first grade because I was cutting pointy fringe rather than straight. Not much has changed in public school except for less art altogether! If kids are given an opportunity to do art is far from creative. It is a crime! I have a friend who teaches art to inmates at San Quentin prison and I can't help but think how many of them might not be there had they had more creative release back when they were in elementary school. Your boys are lucky to have you as their ally!

  • At 8:02 PM, Blogger crazymumma said…

    This is my response to you. This gave me hope so much hope about one year ago when I realized that my younger was just not going to fit the mold. And I am thankful for that (the not fitting), and this, the video.


Post a Comment

<< Home